Skip to main content

Table 2 Comparison of the SPD protocol with other SNP genotyping methods.

From: Reliable allele detection using SNP-based PCR primers containing Locked Nucleic Acid: application in genetic mapping

Method

Accuracy

Cost

Modification

Complexity

Detection equipment/chemicals

Reference

SPD

High

Low

LNA base at 3' end

Low

Standarda

this paper

FRET

High

Medium

Fluorescence

Medium

Optical system

[16]

BAMPER

Medium

High

Bioluminescence

High

PPi assay, Luminometer, Amplifier and Recorder

[28]

PAMSA

Medium

Low

Internal nucleotide mismatch

Medium

Standard

[31]

SNaPshot

High

Very High

Fluorescence

Medium

Sequencer

[32]

AFLP

High

Medium

33P or Fluorescence

Medium

Acrylamide gel or sequencer, Restriction enzymes

[33]

  1. aStandard; consisting of sequencer, thermocycler and agarose gel electrophoresis equipment, FRET; fluorescence resonance energy transfer, PAMSA; PCR amplification of multiple specific alleles, BAMPER; bioluminometric assay using a modified primer extension reaction, PPi; sodium pyrophosphate decahydrate, AFLP; amplified fragment length polymorphism. Assessment of accuracy, cost, complexity of techniques and data interpretation, and robustness follow the criteria proposed by Kofiadi and Rebrikov [34].