Skip to main content

Table 7 Comparison with state-of-the-art counting approaches on the test set of WSC dataset. TasselNetv2 adopts an AlexNet-like architecture in Fig. 6 and is trained from scratch

From: TasselNetv2: in-field counting of wheat spikes with context-augmented local regression networks

Method

Henan Zhengzhou (2012–2013)

Shandong Taian (2012–2013 Camera1)

Overall

#Parameters

MAE

RMSE

MAE

RMSE

MAE

RMSE

Segmentation method in [13]

387.09

436.84

268.03

345.78

317.19

386.22

\(\times\)

CCNN [6]

168.41

214.41

52.40

72.78

101.39

149.91

\(5.70\times 10^5\)

MCNN [5]

149.44

188.34

58.83

75.50

97.08

135.17

\(1.33\times 10^5\)

CSRNet\(^\dagger\) [23]

64.19

88.96

33.26

46.19

46.32

67.63

\(1.63\times 10^7\)

TasselNet [9]

94.97

137.24

36.79

57.37

61.35

99.27

\(6.38\times 10^5\)

TasselNetv2

74.97

113.21

33.12

49.26

50.79

80.66

\(6.38\times 10^5\)

TasselNetv2\(^\dagger\)

61.57

87.67

31.62

47.55

44.27

67.47

\(1.60\times 10^7\)

  1. \(^\dagger\) means the model is finetuned from the pretrained VGG16, and layer-by-layer settings can be found in Additional file. The best performance is italics