Skip to main content

Table 4 Comparison between 5 methods by 6 criteria

From: Dehiscence method: a seed-saving, quick and simple viability assessment in rice

 

Ger.

TTC

EC

DehM

NRSs

Precision

++

++

−

+

−

Seed saving

−

−

+

+

++

Simplicity

++

+

−

+

−

Quickness

−

+

+

+

++

Labor saving

++

−

+

+

++

Single seed screening

−

−

−

+

+

  1. ++: perfectly fit; +: well fit; −: not well fit. Ger.: germination method; TTC: tetrazolium method; EC: electrical conductivity method; DehM: dehiscence method; NRSs: non-invasive, rapid sensing method. Labor-saving is the only criterion by which Deh. neither outperformed Ger., nor NRSs. NRSs here only contain chemometry and calorimetry, not morphological graphing